Skip to content
Sailing Beyond Limits

Phi Phi, Phang Nga or Krabi: Which Day Trip from Phuket?

12 min read

Share on
Aerial view of a small wooded limestone island with a white sandbar and two boats, in the Andaman Sea off Phuket

“Phi Phi or James Bond Island?” is the question almost everyone asks when they look at boat trips from Phuket, and it is a fair one: both are full-day speedboat trips of about eight hours, both start with a hotel pick-up, and both cost a day of your holiday. There is also a third option that gets less attention, the islands of Krabi, and a quieter one close to home, the coral islands south of Phuket. They are different days, not the same day with different names.

This guide compares them on what you see, what kind of day it is, who it suits and when to go, so you can pick one (or two). The trips we link are run by Simba Sea Trips, an independent local operator; we list them on this website with live availability and secure online payment. What we say about the parks and the islands comes from the official or press sources listed at the end; what we say about the trips comes from the trip pages.

The short answer

  • You want the postcard cove, the sharks or the sunset: Phi Phi.
  • You want limestone towers, mangroves, caves and kayaking: Phang Nga Bay, which is where James Bond Island is.
  • You want beaches under cliffs and a day just for your group: the Krabi islands, on a private charter.
  • You want to snorkel with nobody else around and stay close to Phuket: the coral islands, also private.
  • You only have one day and no strong preference: Phi Phi if you travel between November and May, Phang Nga if you prefer scenery to swimming.

The trips side by side

Phi Phi Phang Nga Bay Krabi islands Southern coral islands
What you see Maya Bay, Pileh Lagoon, Viking Cave, Monkey Beach, Bamboo Island James Bond Island, caves of Koh Panak and Koh Hong, Kudu Island Hong Island lagoon, Chicken Island, Phranang Cave Beach, Railay Mai Thon, Coral and Rang Yai islands
Kind of day Swim, snorkel, beach, boat views Kayak, caves, scenery, a Thai lunch Beaches and snorkelling, a long cruise out and back Snorkelling at your own pace
Length (trip pages) About 8 h (sunrise), about 8 h 30 (sunset) About 8 h About 8 h About 7 h
Format Shared small group; private option Shared small group; private option Private charter Private charter
Best for First-time visitors, snorkellers, sunset lovers Scenery, photography, kayakers Couples and groups who want a day to themselves Snorkellers, families who want a calm day
Season Best roughly November to May; Maya Bay closed in August and September Better in the drier months; see the note on the park season below Best in the calmer months, roughly December to April for the Hong lagoon Check the trip page

Phi Phi: the postcard coves

The Phi Phi Islands are part of the Hat Noppharat Thara – Mu Ko Phi Phi National Park, a marine park of about 388 km² in Krabi province with white-sand beaches, coral reefs and limestone cliffs, according to the Thai National Parks site. That is the first surprise: the “Phuket” Phi Phi day trip actually goes to Krabi province, across open water.

What makes the day is the variety packed into one boat: a swim in Pileh Lagoon, snorkelling stops, Viking Cave and Monkey Beach, and Maya Bay, the cove from The Beach. Maya Bay has rules today (boats do not enter the bay, swimming is not allowed, visits are limited) and is closed every year from 1 August to 30 September (Thai National Parks). We cover the details in our Phi Phi and Maya Bay guide.

Our two shared Phi Phi trips are the Phi Phi sunrise trip, which leaves at about 06:00 to reach Maya Bay before the day-trip boats, and the Phi Phi sunset and shark spotting trip, about eight and a half hours and available from November to April, with snorkelling at Bamboo Island and Shark Bay, a beach picnic and the sunset over the Andaman Sea.

Speedboat moored below a limestone cliff with striped fish swimming just below the surface
Snorkelling from the speedboat below the limestone cliffs · Photo: our trip page (Bókun)

Phang Nga Bay: limestone towers and mangroves

Ao Phang Nga National Park was declared a marine national park in 1981, covers about 400 km² and includes the largest native mangrove forests left in Thailand, according to Thai National Parks. Its best-known islet, Khao Phing Kan, is “James Bond Island” from The Man with the Golden Gun (1974); since 1998, regulations keep tourist boats from getting too close to the needle-like Ko Tapu to prevent erosion. The park page itself warns that the island gets very crowded when boat after boat anchors, so go early or choose a small group, and do not expect it to be the whole day: it is one stop among several.

The rest of the bay is the real attraction. The park describes sea caves leading to hidden lagoons, canoeing around Hong Island and the stilt-house village of Ko Panyi, which lies inside the park boundary but is not run by the park authority. Our small-group Phang Nga trip takes about eight hours from Boat Lagoon Marina and combines kayaking into the hidden lagoon of Koh Panak and the caves of Koh Hong, James Bond Island, a swim at Kudu Island and a Thai lunch on the beach. The trip page lists kayaking and national-park fees as included.

A note on the park season. The Thai National Parks page says the park is open from 15 October to 15 May and closed in the rainy season, with fees of 300 baht for foreign adults and 150 for children “as of June 2022”. Other guides say the bay stays open all year and only closes for storms, and fees can change. Because the sources disagree, check the trip page and the operator’s latest note before you plan around those dates.

Krabi islands: beaches under the cliffs

Railay (Rai Leh) is a small peninsula in Krabi province that, according to Wikipedia, is reachable only by boat because limestone cliffs cut off the mainland. The Hong Islands belong to Than Bok Khorani National Park, established in 1998 and covering about 103 km² of land and islands (Wikipedia). Their central lagoon is surrounded by steep cliffs and reached by kayak through a narrow cave opening, according to Thai Holiday Guide, which also recommends December to April, when the sea is calmest.

Do not mix this Hong up with the Koh Hong of Phang Nga Bay, which is a different island: the same source warns about the name. It is an easy mistake because both appear on boat-trip lists.

Our Private Krabi Islands speedboat charter leaves from Boat Lagoon Marina and has breakfast on the beach at Hong Island, enters its lagoon, snorkels at Chicken Island, visits Phranang Cave Beach and Railay Beach, then has a Thai lunch and relaxes at Coconut Cape. The trip page describes the route as about 50 km direct by sea against 180 km by road, which is the operator’s figure, not one we have measured. It is about eight hours in total, so it is a long day on the water; the compensation is that it is only your group.

Limestone cliffs covered in vegetation rising from calm turquoise water off the Krabi coast
Limestone cliffs rising from the sea on the Krabi route · Photo: our trip page (Bókun)

The quieter option: coral islands south of Phuket

If the question is “where can we snorkel without a crowd?”, the answer may not be any of the three. The Private Coral Islands snorkel charter goes to the quieter coral islands of southern Phuket (Mai Thon, Coral and Rang Yai) with just your group, in clear water and at your own pace, for about seven hours. Breakfast, hotel pick-up and guide are included. The trip page says the national park fee and lunch are not included and are paid separately according to the operator, so check the exact amounts on the page before you book and plan for them on the day.

How to choose

  • Families with young children: the shared trips accept children aged 4 to 12 (infants 0 to 3 travel free) and run in small groups. In our view Phi Phi and the sunset trip are the more varied days for children; the Phang Nga day involves more sitting in the boat and, if they join, kayaking. On every trip, children must be accompanied by an adult, and the trips are not recommended for pregnant travellers or for people with heart or back problems.
  • Couples: Phi Phi at sunset (November to April) or a private charter, which lets you set the pace.
  • Snorkelling: Phi Phi sunrise has two snorkelling stops of about 45 minutes each; the sunset trip includes snorkelling equipment; the private coral-islands charter is built around it.
  • Photography: Phang Nga Bay for the limestone scenery and the light on the mangroves; Phi Phi sunrise for Maya Bay without the day-trip boats; the sunset trip for the golden hour.
  • Short on time: every full-day trip here is about eight hours. If you only have an afternoon, the private Phang Nga Bay sunset charter is about four and a half hours, leaving at 14:30.

Our shared trips from Phuket

Shared or private?

A shared small-group trip is the best value if you are two to four people or want to meet others: you pay per person, with lower prices for children aged 4 to 12 and free places for infants up to 3. The operator may reschedule a shared trip if fewer than six seats are booked, as stated on the trip pages.

A private charter makes sense for a group of friends or a family of five or more, for a day with no schedule but your own, or for a route that does not exist as a shared trip, like Krabi. The price is for the group and depends on its size: the total is the same from 2 to 4 guests and then rises by a fixed amount per extra guest, so the price per person drops as the group grows, and the calendar shows the total for your party. Two of the shared routes also exist privately: Phi Phi (the private Phi Phi sunrise charter) and Phang Nga (the private James Bond Island charter); see all our private charters in Thailand.

If you have two days

Do not put Phi Phi and Phang Nga on consecutive mornings if you can avoid it: both start early and a rest day in between makes both better. A good pairing is:

  1. Day one, Phi Phi (sunrise, or sunset from November to April) for the swimming and snorkelling.
  2. A day off on the beach.
  3. Day two, Phang Nga Bay for the scenery, or the private Krabi charter if you want a quieter, longer day.

If you are travelling in August or September, Maya Bay is closed to visitors; our Phi Phi trips go to Bamboo Island instead and you see Maya Bay from the boat, as the trip page explains, so Phang Nga or the coral islands may be the better first choice.

Practical checklist

  • Pick-up: complimentary anywhere in Phuket (outside Phuket an extra charge applies depending on the distance, and the operator confirms the exact amount). The operator sends the exact time the day before.
  • Bring: your passport number (not the passport itself), swimwear, a towel, sunscreen, a hat, a camera and some cash for tips and drinks.
  • Not included: alcoholic drinks and tips for the crew.
  • Park fees: Phi Phi Don, Phi Phi Leh and Mai Phai island have a special service fee of 400 baht for foreign adults and 200 for children, according to The Thaiger, February 2024, citing the park chief; scuba divers pay 200 baht more (Thai National Parks). Our Phang Nga and sunset trips list national-park fees as included; for the others, read what the trip page says and confirm current amounts, because they change.
  • Guides: English and Thai.

Know where you are staying? Read the full Phuket destination guide or browse all our trips from Phuket.

Quick answers

  • Which is better, Phi Phi or James Bond Island? Neither is better; they are different days. Phi Phi is about swimming, snorkelling and Maya Bay; Phang Nga is about scenery, caves and kayaking, with James Bond Island as one stop.
  • How long does each day trip take? About eight hours on our shared Phi Phi sunrise and Phang Nga trips, about eight and a half on the sunset trip, about eight on the Krabi charter and about seven on the coral-islands charter.
  • Can you do Phi Phi and Phang Nga in one day? Not on our trips: each is already about eight hours. Choose one per day.
  • Which trip is best for snorkelling? Phi Phi, or the private coral-islands charter if you want to be alone in the water.
  • Is the Krabi trip too far from Phuket? The trip page gives about 50 km by sea against 180 km by road, with a full day of about eight hours.

Sources

Ready to sail?

Trips from the area, with live availability.

Keep reading